Wilco Is Terrible And Hates You
1 Aug
[We interrupt our countdown of Wilco's best songs for a word from the 2005-2009 Diamond Chalice Award recipient from the Player Hater's Ball, Off Tackle Empire's Graham Filler.]
Please Don’t Feel Obligated To Listen To Wilco
I went to a Bob Dylan concert last year. Ol’ Bob is getting, well, old. Anyways, he garbled through about five minutes of something incomprehensible, jammed for awhile, and then fell asleep, snoring loudly for an hour. Not a great experience. Then I realized it was just a dream and the whole thing was actually a Wilco album.
I have a philosophy on why people may enjoy Wilco. Indi music wasn’t the monstrous beast it is now back in 2002, so when this non-pandering piece of understated American gritty “The Band”-esque music came out, it surprised a lot of people. “What is this intriguing band” they asked, “what is this dull, dreary sound they have created,” they asked.

I am not, contrary to Patrick Vint’s assertions, a hipster. I’m a lawyer who knows good and bad music when he hears it. I do kind of look like that guy though. Dammit.
Anyways, now that we have nuanced, awesome indi music that pulls us all the way from The National’s morose awesomeness to Band of Horses balladic genius to Arcade Fire’s ramshackle operatic epics…we know what good indi music is. But back then we didn’t, so Wilco filled a void. So now everyone can stop moping around with your coors light in dark bars and replaying “Jesus Etc.” thinking about your lost love…and go listen to real music.
I have a story about the Sky Blue Sky album…I heard a song called Hate It Here…I thought it was weird, I was experimenting, I decided to keep listening to it…so I added it to my Ipod, played it a few times, realized how barebones and uninteresting it was…and eventually hated it.
Stunning. And then Sky Blue Sky apparently sucks as a whole album.
Like seriously, I could see, maybe, just maybe, getting drunk in Bloomington, Illinois and hanging out in a nice dive bar next to a strip mall, and hearing, “Jesus Etc.” or even “I’m The Man Who Loves You”…and possibly feeling like yeah, this reads the mood right.
But that’s it.
Goddamn is Wilco boring. At best, it’s background music during the heartbreaking part of movies. But the goddamn generic nature of the music kills me. And the new stuff is more Jason Mraz than Radiohead.
I actually think Wilco would be a decent band if people didn’t slobber all over them. My expectations were raised. Hell, in honor of being the Wilco hater, I decided to listen to them all day. Unfortunately it was making my day bad so I switched to something I enjoyed..
I think people should do what they want in life. One professor at Miami (OH) always lectured about living your best life; don’t be weighed down by expectations or what you think others want. So my fellow music lovers, don’t feel like you must like Wilco. You won’t lose your Indi Card for admitting it’s a boring band that sort of peaked years ago and has been surpassed by legions of better bands. Just move on to all the amazing music out there and explore the vast wild world of genius songwriters and brilliant front men. You’re going to thank me.
Let’s talk about a few songs by Wilco.
Handshake Drugs – This might be the worst song I’ve ever heard. What part of this am I supposed to enjoy? I realize barebones is cool, but barebones without any pop sensibility is just a jam session.
Kamera – I would put this song on, assuming I was using it as background party music where no one actually had to listen to the song. Music is supposed to draw you in and inspire, not make you fall asleep.
War on War – Probably the best song I listened to all day and it was completely forgettable.
Jesus etc. – Ah, how understated, I get it, Wilco is always so fucking understated. I’ll bet they go to McDonalds and get their meals downsized and with less flavor. I’m getting a distinct emo country feel here and that’s not a compliment.
I’m The Man Who Loves You – WOW. So now Wilco is doing their impression of Phoenix during a jam session. This sounds like Radiohead without any understanding of say, catchy or intriguing musical concepts. I also thought there was some Simon and Garfunkel here, but I’m not sure because I fell asleep during the song.
I’m Trying To Break Your Heart – I feel like I’m getting somewhere here. I feel like I learned something. Yup, Wilco is the American version of earlier Radiohead! Oh, but with less talent, less pop sensibility, less irony…
Raining on someone’s parade is never fun, but it’s necessary. I wanted to finish with a few thoughts…and then of course some song suggestions for when you toss out all those Wilco albums. I love music…and I really truly love the idea of “Indi” music. I love the idea that always ALWAYS, new music will be out there to discover, popular or barely known. But with this vast amount of great music that exists, more attention needs to be paid to band or artists that spark the imagination, that show you something new, whatever that may be. The latest Wilco CD is by far the most accessible of their work, but it’s “dad rock” blandness makes me unable to give it an extended listen. Why spend time on Jeff Tweedy’s Dylan Lite when I can be replaying Justin Vernon’s haunting, intriguingly grainy vocals?
To sum up:
Wilco: Background music for a Wes Anderson film. Way in the background.
Wilco: Something the limousine chauffer plays at low volume as we drive to the cemetery to bury my gramma.
BONUS FEATURE!
Here are some songs you should probably go listen to instead.
Bon Iver – For Emma (In Paris, live, I just am not sure it gets better than this.)
Jeff Buckley – Vancouver (His angriest song, and that’s saying something.)
Neutral Milk Hotel – Aeroplane Over The Sea (I know you’ve all heard it. I don’t care. This is how you make a record. This is provocative. And when he says, oh hell I’m getting emotional, I’ll just cut and paste…)
Now, how I remember you
How I would push my fingers through your mouth
To make those muscles move
That made your voice so smooth and sweet
And now we keep where we don’t know
All secrets sleep in winter clothes
With one you loved so long ago
Now he don’t even know his name
Jeff Mangum – I Love How You Love Me (Covering a Phil Spector girl band song from the 60’s and just killin’ it, killin’ it so good.)
Adam Haworth Stephens – Heights of Diamonds (Lead singer of Two Gallants, his solo album was too light for some, but man, this track will take you somewhere.)
Bright Eyes – Approximate Sunlight (Now that’s some haunting shit.)
Jens Lekman – Friday Night at the Drive In Bingo (Never heard anything like this, something I can say for most of Lekman’s stuff. Brilliant use of horns…)
The National – Slow Show (You want depressing? This is actually a love song, but they make anything sound depressing. Pay attention the drums at the end, very moving use of drums. Go listen to Conversation #16 also.)



